Skinning Challenge Thread

It's cool!!! :o
Cool face too!!! :o
I think i'll be on the last place

Don't worry
It's just that i have a problem, WHY IS IT SO? Only team color, again i hate this bullsh**. does anyone have any ideas how to fix that? In wc3v it's ok, but in WE there is only teamcolor :( i still can't find a way to fix that

-- My Judgement -- THE HARSHEST

1st skin (The Rifleman) - Very blurry and not undead..just looks like he's been doused with paint. I am not very inclined to download that one. 3/10

2nd skin (Footman) - The parts that are edited are pretty nice but its blurry. I think more details and sharpness are in order, i like dhte oriignal, so i'll give you 4.5/10

3rd skin (Goblins) - Terrible. 1/10. I see nothign undead about them.

4th skin (Priest) - Clean, but a bit unnatural for an average "living or undead" skin, the best out of the lot, however. 5.8/10

(dont mind the harshER ratings im trying to be honest here.)
Happy belated halloween everyone.
Hope you had fun.

i didnt know it was 2 weeks! maybe ill enter (again) if thats allowed.
heres a little screenshot, i tried to be original or something, you tell me if it is.
kinda looks like a warhammer skeleton unit. anyway this is still very wip, i only did his face for a part.

:DDDDDDDDDDD
Windrunner - this is fun! :D Realy, i laughed too much ^_^ Funny skin! It's kinda...ummm...funny...

*ps* Yay! I am at third place .... from total 4 available o_O

Oh come on, ah neverminde, i wanted to enter the lichking like footman, but aah.
Already 2 judjes judjed so what the hell. (maby someone can still judge my footman's 2 version? when i will get some better screenies)
Edit: and once again, the Dryad contest... forgotten
Edit again: Ok, i duno if anyone is going to judge this, but i think you should see this one ^_^
The LichKing-ish Undead Footman
As i sad it's 100% freehand!
I can show the unwrap is someone wants to.

i havent done anything actually to it, didnt shade and dodge and stuff.
btw, i dont really care if i win or not, i just want to make skins!

EDIT: Bloody hell! (kicks himself) i forgot we could only make humans and orcs!

WAIT! ITS TWO WEEKS?
Then take my judgement away...if i cna still enter?
I am lsot...i have time to finish it by next weekend!!!!!!!!
-HORUSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

And umm...its interesting...the umm footman...its not iundead tho....i dunno what IT IS.....????

Nooooo!

Its one week! its over! those judgmens are in! thats Them!

It only lasted one week! where that other comment came from about 2 weeks i have no idea!

i Said it would be finishing in a day the day before!

*Sigh* its over... saikann said he wouldent judge and Ardvark- is puting up the scores 2night ;)

So far i think im ahead

reaper is close behind though so it should be interesting to see who takes it

Remember, winner gets rep from all contestants AND judges

Oh! and its too late and that Drani dosent count as one of the skinnable models

-Garith

r00ts Undead Rifleman - 4/10
everything is too blurry. it all looks basically the same - gray. then you have the purple sticking out like a sore thumb. it looks more forsaken type than the scourge (the original theme right). to sum it up... too blurry. your average wc3sear.ch skin.

--------------------------------------

kelna's undead sappers - 2.5/10
not really undead. not much is changed either. the only thing i see going for it is the strategic alphaing

-------------------------------------

thereaper's footman - 3/10 + 5/10
this one didnt really get fair ratings cuz there were two different versions. the first version was what got rated by the others so just listen to that, but i wanted to say my opinion on the second one.

v.1 - 3/10
doesnt really strike me as undead... it just seems like a footman that's been charcoaled gray and then a few purp ribbons on him...

v.2 - 5/10
still doesnt strike me as undead, just a footman that crept out of a lagoon. the texture is nice, but overused. thats basically all it is.

------------------------------

garith's undead priest - 6.5/10
the face is kinda bland, not much definite shading, just like 5 opacity dodge + burn. the texture on the cape is great. the arms + legs are as well. what r those gray things on his chest? the strip things? they dont really look like bone. but good nonetheless.

there's my verdict.....

OOOOOOOOps sorry about that, the deadline was until 2nd November i thought 2 weeks, silly me :god_help_us:
Anywayz, good job all

Yay! rep 2 me! (Supposedly all judges and participants )

I win! im going to PM horus now to see if i can make the next contest (I have a really interesting idea for this one)!

Well those strips on his chest are ment to tattered cloth from the orignal skin... if you look it has this cloth running across it. i asumed they might be still intact

Anyway, thanks for judging, rep 4 u (If i can...hmmm)
and... thats it for now! Ill bee looking foward to the next contest when its made! (Whether it be me or hurus or whoever)

Keep skinning!
-Garith

Maby a Murgul skin edit? Cuz i haven't seen any edited murgul skins but that's how you want.

So what will be total judgement?
garith - 1st
reaper - 2nd
me - 3rd
kelna - 4th
???

BTW, garith - nice cape!

Guss so...

And guys WHAT ABOUT THE DRYAD CONTEST???
Isn't anyone going to judge it?