2 Player Map - Icelands

I was hoping I could get some feedback on this map before posting it on my website. I'm not so sure about the islands whether to make them connected to the mainland or leave them as is. Also, the creeps... not sure about their level and placement. Any feedback would be greatly appreciate (good or bad).

I find there doesn't seem to be many 1on1 maps so I've made quite a few. They've been set up to work as best as possible if playing against the computer.

Some screenshots of the map:


Another one here

Thanks

Personally I think you need to ask experienced melee players for an opinion on melee maps. It looks good, but from my experiences in making melee maps for Starcraft, you have to think about the possible strategies and tactics you want people to use. If I were you, I'd play the map with people on batlle.net and ask them for comments.

Actually, I played it on bnet for a few nights but got mixed reviews about the islands which is why I posted it here to get a different opinion from a more campaign related set of people. I realize that maybe malee maps aren't big around here but I assume everyone plays them now and then and having seen some of the great work that people around here have done, I figured I'd get more of an "experienced" opinion.

But I suppose you're right in that respect that it will ultimately come down to malee players and what they like so perhaps I'll have to give it some more time on bnet and see what transpires.
Thanks for you input :gsmile: