Minas Tirith - Screenshots

Hello, I'm in the process of making the LOTR: Minas Tirith map. I wanted to show you some screenys of what it looks like so far, and your comments/suggestions on the terrain, etc. Thanks:)


Screenshot1

Hey Jana you are currently working for HRM!!

Hey man its no problem im working on my extra map too:ggani:

Its looks good!

screenshot2

Yeah I'm working on HRM aswell:P This is just something I'm also working on :P

and thats strange, it didnt show doodads on first screeny

Last one:////

YOU HAVE GOOD TALENT !!!!!!!

That's a pretty odd thing to say...

The screens look wast......... not wast enough, however :P
The city should have badass 3-level tall walls that protect it, and stuff.
After all... It's Minas Thirith... not some pussy elven city (heeheehee)

I'd suggest adding some taller walls as well as some huge giant towers inside the city.

Other than that, it looks pretty good, even if the ground in screenshot 2 could use a bit of smoothing.

Ok thanks, ill try making the walls higher, and making the towers bigger and smoothing the terrain a bit. I'll make more ScreenShots soon...

Yes.....its seems good jana glad you are working with us 8))

Wow, another map based around Lord of the Rings that looks very bad. Minas Tirith is kinda of, you know, a circle. But while the Warcraft3 engine can't do a circle, you could at least make it resemble one.

But instead of just bashing it, I'll help you out with some reference pics:
Minas Tirith

Minas Tirith Zoom

God that's a lot of detail

I hope that helps. Try and make something that does the White City justice, at least. Thanks in advance

-spartan

The only thing I can say is to make it 7 walls high. Overall looks good, but needs some polish (Unless your worried about lag). I would reccomend, aswell that all elven wall things are capped off:D

So, I should make my walls out of the hill tool, making it high. Only problem so far are the walls are too low..and I agree to that.

Gahhh!!! Noise tool!!! NEVER use noise tool. Also there's a way to get the look of some really high cliffs without making the steps.

You may want to put some more detail into the Pelennor Fields and maybe even construct the Rammas Echor.

Also, who are you going to turn into hero units? Because if you leave out Prince Imrahil, I think I'd cry... he's such a badass.

Post some more stuff please.

Will soon.