| 01-30-2004, 04:44 AM | #1 |
please, dont spam this up! this thread is to rate the skinner who posts above you in the following categories: Skin quality: Critisizm Given: Skin Production Rate: Usefulness to the Community: (50% sharing files 50% tutorials/general help) Overall: for instance, say Joebob123 is the world's best skinner. He'd get a 10/10 in skin quality, but say Joebob123 only gives "good skin" etc and doesnt tell you what to fix, so he'd get like a 2/10 in crits. Lets say he takes forever to skin, so he'd get a 3/10 in production rate, but he is very useful and gets a 10/10, because he helps a lot and puts all of his stuff in dl. His overall would be 6.25/10. If you see a good skinner, dont automatically give them all 10/10's. a 10 on this shud be HARD to get, as in if i see like more than 2 10/10s here, someones been doin a spammin! ONLY RATE THE PERSON ABOVE YOU! NO WEIRD FRACTIONS! keep at 10/10, i dont wanna see "3.821/7.33312" or "5/5", 10/10 is SIMPLE! If you've never seen the person above you skin, rate the person above them, OR don't post at all. [averaging for overall for idiots:] I know a lot of people here are stupid, and a lot arent. add their scores, divide by 4 (since theres 4 categories) and thats what #/10 they get. |
| 01-30-2004, 07:20 AM | #2 |
Skin quality: 7.5/10 From several of the skins i've seen they have decent qaulity, However in some parts color schemes do not fit it, or it lacks something that defines the theme. Critisizm Given: 5/10 Normally a short content, followed by a (Disturbing) set of floating streaking arthas heads. Skin Production Rate: 7/10 While i've seen plenty of skins i cant really justify how fast kurama does his skins. However i've seen about average of threads in the gallery by him. Usefulness to the Community:5.5/10 I've never seen anything all to detailed on how to improve by kurama but he at least seems comfortable with sharing his work. Overall:6.75/10 Kurama seems to be at least a decent skinner, and has room to improve. However his work has a akward and sometimes disturbing creativity. |
| 01-30-2004, 08:30 AM | #3 |
Skin quality: 8/10 Very cool looking skins Critisizm Given: 0.000000001/10 Almost none i guess... Skin Production Rate: 4/10 :( i dun see you post much... or issit just me? Usefulness to the Community:5/10 very helpful guy indeed :D your skins are good but not to the community i guess, never seen you releasing your works :P Overall:7/10 well zap have been here longer than alot of the skinners here... hes good |
| 01-30-2004, 05:17 PM | #4 |
Skin quality: 8/10 You're VERY good, but not the world's best :D Critisizm Given: 6/10 You give little critisizm, but when you ever give some, its usually helpful Skin Production Rate: 5/10 Havent seen u post a skin for a lOOOOOOng time! (or is it just me?) Usefulness to the Community: 6/10 Although you share little, you have a helpful thread in requests, and ur a moderator; mods help a loT! But sadly, you've almost never shared a skin :nono: Overall: 6.25/10 :D (yes im hard on ratings) -ps- Zap? me 1 word comments? havent been readin my posts lately have ya :ggani: oh wait, my nudist arthas phase in life :D nvm :D |
| 01-31-2004, 12:48 AM | #5 |
well, since kurama posted above me, i'll rate alfred instead Skin Qaulity: 8.5/10 Some really nice looking skins, but some just lack - still, most are very great. Critisizm Given: 7.5/10 Sometimes i just get one word comments or a little more, but not alaways to much - still though. You have given some fairly useful commentary before. Skin Production Rate: 6.5/10 Haven't seen all to many skins from you, But i know skinning isn't your primary subject anyways. Usefulness to the Community: 9/10 I'm basing this rather on how you do your MDL editing, Considering you do it for free, and release enough of it, And i believe you've written a tutorail on the subject? If i'm not wrong :) Overall: 7.5/10 Pretty good skinner, even better MDL editor. |
| 01-31-2004, 10:30 AM | #6 |
Skin Quality: 8.0/10 Some really good skins and a the rare bad ones. Criticism Given: 5/10 Seems to give good crits.. He loses points here for not liking my skins :p Skin Production Rate: 6/10 Seems to do a lot. Doesn't always post it though. Likes to redo stuff.. Usefulness to Community: 8/10 Usually releases all of his skins.. even one's he's not supposed to -_- Overall: 8/10 Overall not bad.. Ripped some cool Starcrafts icons :p -Fiery |
| 01-31-2004, 10:44 AM | #7 |
Skin Quality: 7/10 i luv that dragon... nvr seen yur skins so often Criticism Given: ?/10 hmmmm nvr heard u giving crits... perhaps ive been in modelling forum!? Skin Production Rate: 5/10 like i said, almost nvr seen yur skins Usefulness to Community: 0/10 hmmm... sry nvr seen u released anything lol Overall: 6.5/10 not bad... u have the potential... btw u forgot to give me credits for helping u in the wings |
| 01-31-2004, 11:32 AM | #8 |
Skin Quality: 8/10 Alfred's skins are getting better though he seems to be working on geoset merging at the moment Criticism Given: 7/10 well thought out crits/comments about Skins, always tells the skinner what needs to be done. Production Rate: 5/10: Alfred has been slack lately havent seen nemore lately. usefullness to the community: 8/10: as a moderator, skinner, modder and friendp; he is a vital part of our comminuty :) Overall: 8/10 |
| 01-31-2004, 01:25 PM | #9 |
Skin Quality: 7/10 gettin there Hybrid ur skins and models show us ur gonna get better in the future... i think... Crit Quality: ?/10 never seen you crit much but then i dont see much of you Production Quality: 10/10 You been makin stuff like theres no 2morow... Usefullness: ?/10 again im sorry but I dont know LOL Overall: 8/10 Your great keep it up and you will be a huge skinner in no time... |
| 01-31-2004, 04:06 PM | #10 |
Final Tyrant Skin Quality: 8.5/10 I haven't seen much of your work or don't remember it. But from what I seen it's great. Crit Quality: 3/10 too much use of the 5/5 image rate. You stop posting any text and add that Production Quality: 5/10 Like i said I haven't seen much of your work or I dont remember it. Usefullness: 7/10 A good member all around just needs to post more crits. Overall: 7/10 Looken good so far just needs to improve a few areas. |
| 01-31-2004, 09:00 PM | #11 |
Mock1 Skin Quality: 8/10 Great skins.. Very creative ideas. Crit Quality: 9/10 Posts tons of crits. Production Quality: 7/10 Been posting tons of skins lately, Good job. Usefullness: 10/10 Good crits.. good skins.. A site devoted to downloading skins/models.. A mod.. Quite important to the community. Overall: 9/10 Overall good guy... |
| 01-31-2004, 10:12 PM | #12 |
Who the hell are you? Never seen your skins. |
| 01-31-2004, 10:26 PM | #13 |
WhiteHorn Skin Quality: 9/10 I have never seen any thing better than those skins, cept some could use more work... Crit Quality: 5/10 I dont know... Production Quality: 8/10 I dont know... Usefullness: 8/10 Hahaha!!! Edit: You made ur point... 8 for 8 skins Overall: 7.5/10 Im not very social in these forums so... i dotn notice much and i made some of those cruddy skins in the dl section... i was bored, the metal claws, and that *shudders* human death knight |
| 01-31-2004, 10:33 PM | #14 |
I don't know you either, but I'd like to point out that I have 8 or more skins available for download, heck the most downlaoded happens to be my Waywatcher hero. |
| 01-31-2004, 10:45 PM | #15 |
Whitehorn Skin Quality: 9/10 Always looks good. I often don't have any crits to improve upon it. Crit Quality: 9/10 One of the only people who actually will tell you how to improve. He is very honest Production Quality: 10/10 Insane amounts of skins. Usefullness: 8.5/10 Good crits and good skins his honestly usally comes along with an insult. This brings him down from the views of some. I've seen him flaming before. Overall: 9.5/10 We are lacking good skinners currently. We need more people at this calibur. |