Should I finish this?!

Alright... I was skinning a Mountain Giant to look like a 'Mountain Man' (some kind of mix between Ogre and Dwarf I'm guessing). I've got the face done (still gonna tweak it a lil probably). After modifying it about 8 times because of the re-wrap, I got tired of it.

I want to know if you guys think that this is good enough for me to finish the rest of the skin. It will take a long time, and my plans are to make him a large red bread (try to fix the eyebrows a bit while i'm at it). Change his leaf suit to look more like some kind of tattered leather clothes, and of course make the rest of his body look a lot more human.

So whadda ya think? Try to finish, or drop it in the recycling bin where its supposed to be...?

Thank you for your time.

-MadBagOfHorses

Edit: Sorry this is in the wrong place! I coulda swore I was in the works in progress part when I hit 'New Thread'. Sorry!

The face looks pretty good, but change the lips. They look like they have lipstick on them. I say finish it.

Do you want honesty? If not dont read the following : no

Yeah I had trouble getting the lips the right color (I tried about three shades, but all of them looked like lipstick in the screenies).

Jester: I would actually like feedback about it as well please. You say that I shouldn't try to finish it... I would like to know why, so if I have spare time and decide TO finish it I know what to change.

Do whatever you want, why are you even asking us?
but please change the lips....right away

Heh, I made them a slightly darker red (trying to get them as close to reality as possible, but like I said, I'm having troubles).

I want your opinion on this because:

A) I might not even use it, but instead submit it to wc3sear.ch, which would be wasting my time if no one likes it.
B) I need to know what I should change if anyone does even remotely like it, to make it better.
and finally...
C) IF I do put it in a map or campaign of mine, I want to know beforehand what people's reaction to it will be.

Right now, I am leaning towards at least doing some more with it.

-MadBagOfHorses

Edit: Ok, and I've got an update. I changed the lip color (still doesn't tickle my fancy, but it looks better), I made the beard (I don't think it looks to bad), and made his face a bit scruffier (like he hasn't shaved).

Please gimme a bit of feedback. Thanks!

No offense, but his face looks like he was transsexual retard. You sgould get rid of that lips at all.

i agree with the doobiemancer. fix the face...

Simply... ah no.

As I said before, the face is extremely hard to fix using only skinning techniques (due to the way the skin is wrapped on the model). I am not a modeller, nor do I want to be one.

If I do get rid of the lips, what should I do? Have a black hole there? No, that would look worse. I will play around some more.

Goongoon. Did you not read my post: .

I need feedback on this to make it work. A simple no does nothing but anger people. I want to know what is wrong with it if you don't like it so much. So I can fix it.

Other than that, thank you Flamey, Muoteck, and anti-hero. I will try simply removing the lips, and see if I can do anything good there. Oh yeah, what do you guys think of the beard so far? more detail? Different color? More facial hair?

Thank you very much for your time.

-MadBagOfHorses

lol a new mountain woman

Lol. OK OK! I made some fixes. He looks more like a dude now...

I have a proposition for you, please go and try to reskin a model that
a. has good wrapping
b. actually resembles a human being
c. realistically has a chance of being a fun skinning exercise for you.

Also read tutorials, lots of tutorials

planet quake
Identity Crisis

wtf you ask a question and then we reply to that question. next time call your thread : would actually like feedback

Hey it looks a lot better now. Don't listen what the others say, they're just jealous. Just listen the advices some are giving. Never give up hope :D