My first Icons

Here is my 5 first icons, i think they are pretty good

they are good but i dont like the lower left 1, its just not... pretty :) cant explain really but i just dislike it . others are ok

I think they look quite good, actually.. but yeah, the lower left could use some more work.. all-in-all good job.

Keep it up.

well, the lower left icon was my first freehand icon but yea it could use some work

Generally you need more shading, and blending. Try not to make them took too cartoony.

Also experiment with different textures

Cartoony looks great if it's a consistent style, but not if you're really going WCIII'ish.

Lower left one needs maybe a smaller bottom jaw? I mean, it's not particularly fantastic or anything (The dwarf one I think is the best actually.) it is still very much usable.