Instant notification fails

I've had this problem ever since I started on this site. I have my options setup to send email notifications when people reply to my posts.

Except the emails never arrive.

To make things even more confusing, I do get emails when I get a private message! I double checked my settings and they all look correct.

Is your email program blocking the emails?

Maybe you don't have auto-subscription on? (Where you subscribe to all threads automatically if you post in them). I'm not sure; the feature works for me.

I'm definitely subscribed to the threads: I use that page in my user cp to see if there have been any replies. I also checked my spam folder and there was nothing there from wc3c. If it was being canned it would do the private messages, too, though.

Strilanc, I have the same problem. I don't know why it doesn't work properly and the last time I asked there was apparently no issue with it for some people. So... I dunno.